Chris Correa, AMA Historian

Chris Correa, AMA's Resident Historian

Two Bits

By Chris Correa
January 1, 2024

     I end the year with 2 important bits.

     Bit One: Epilogue to December’s Col. Hoover Article

     Note that this column is not the Paul Hoover Monthly.  As important and intriguing as he is, there are many more lives to trace and events to consider, but I have new information and one face-palm of an error to explain.

     It’s distressing how so many hours of obsessive proofreading can still fall short.  I wrote, “[t]he Recall showed that he graduated from Franklin & Marshall College – but not until 1932, at age 27.”  That was a typo about a typo.  The yearbook actually gives the still-wrong year of 1930 for his F&M graduation, when he would’ve been 25.  Instead, we know that he completed his undergraduate studies on-schedule in 1927.

     That’s an important correction because of what I learned next from my collaborators.  While the next two years of his life remain a mystery, an exhaustive search by archivists Chaoya and Alex at the University of Wisconsin in Madison found that a Paul Vance Hoover was a student in the summer session of 1929.  Evangeline Ann Gahn, an archivist at the University of Maryland, confirmed that for school terms 1930-32, he was a graduate student taking courses in French literature in the college of education.  Then, Carolyn Campion at Severn found documentation of his faculty employment at her school by 1929.  Conclusion: Hoover was busy, commuting roughly 33 miles between taking classes in College Park and teaching classes in Severna Park.

     It was how Carolyn learned this that was the next gem.  Clipped from at least one unidentified newspaper, she found 3 articles from March 28, 1930, pasted into an archive scrapbook.  The headlines:

  1. BLOOD TRANSFUSION FAILS TO SAVE FRED LINKOUS; FLUID GIVEN BY SEVERN TEACHER
  2. GRID STAR DIES AFTER FRIENDS GIVE HIM BLOOD
  3. FORTY PUPILS OFFER BLOOD FOR LINKOUS

     In short, a Severn teacher, coach, and recent UMD “athletic star” got blood poisoning from a tooth extraction.  After a hemorrhage during emergency surgery, Severn got the call late on the 27th that his last hope was a transfusion.  Teachers Paul Hoover and August Keifer rushed about 40 students north to Baltimore, arriving around midnight.  Of everyone tested, Keifer was a match, but Linkous died the next morning surrounded by his family.  He was 25.

     Death and blood tied Hoover to another teacher, this time at the end of his Severn period.  Rich found census records confirming that William John Hoover, at Severn School, was indeed Paul’s older brother by 9 years.  He also confirmed that William died in 1942, aged 46.  BJ d’Orsay ’70 then found a short obituary in the Baltimore Evening Sun but with no cause of death.  I sent William’s date of death to Carolyn so she could search her archive, and, also in a scrapbook, she found a much more detailed obituary clipping from an unnamed newspaper.

     Her findings added key details.  William had been sick for 5 years before he died and “two years ago was relieved of the strenuous task of coaching the football squad, but his death came quite suddenly.”  No cause of death was given here either, but on the same scrapbook page is a clipping from an editorial by Paul Menton, sports editor for the Evening Sun.  He calls Hoover “one of the most thoughtful men in high school athletics.  He might be living today if he had spent less time worrying over the boys he handled and more about himself.”  That devotion helps explain his 23-game win streak from 1928-30 and the “crack 1935 team”.

     This scrapbook page also sharpens the question I asked last month.  Why did Col. Hoover depart after at least 10 years and travel far from home and family to take virtually the same job in Ft. Defiance – and why leave while his brother’s health was failing?  We know nothing about William’s personality or his relationship with Paul, but I can’t help but wonder if Severn was simply too small for two ambitious Hoovers.  William was a WWI veteran and still a coaching institution when his brother resigned in 1939, so I imagine Paul wanting a place to build his own reputation far from where he was kid brother to THE Coach Hoover.

     Maybe, but we’ll never know.

     Bit Two: Luck of the Draw

     This was just a test run, so BJ said any stack of old papers would do.  Trying to streamline our document scanning, he was testing if the many kinds of old paper in our archive would slide safely through the scanner.  I had a box in my office.  I opened it and handed over the first folder I touched.  I never expected this would blow a gaping hole in my AMA story.

     History is never complete.  Some facts are always missing.  Even the most obsessively documented life has moments or details that were never recorded, because no recording device captures all moments.  They can be too quiet for the ear and microphone or too far from the eye and camera.  The brain is worse.  It tends to slough off what doesn’t interest the observer, and even so-called memorable events start fading, morphing, and condensing from the moment they’re made.  We just hope that the remaining details are enough to tell a true story and draw useful conclusions.

     I think about this constantly when I tell the story of your school.  The big broad details are clear enough, like the continents and oceans visible to astronauts.  While their view from orbit is sure pretty, they’re effectively blind to the activity of life at the surface.  This leaves out so much information, that countless misconceptions of this planet would be inevitable if that perspective was all they had.  Likewise, I can wander the campus, read the publications, study photos, and record oral histories.  They’re all vital, but untold thousands of mundane pages that document the daily operations remain unaccounted for.  So long as the ink and paper survive, the data on those sheets is uncorrupted from the moment it was typed.  While we have many large boxes of old files, we’ve simply lacked the manpower to sort, scan, and organize them, let alone read them.  For the time being, the best we can do is preserve them for when we can do that work.

     In the meantime, I’ve gathered a vast, vivid story that’s full of holes and contradictions papered over with guesses and assumptions.  When they relate to the #1 most asked question, Why did the school close?, what I guess and what I assume may linger longest in the memories of our visitors, so I’d better be right.

     Vietnam, Stagflation, Mismanagement: these are the mortal wounds described in the standard AMA postmortem.  The third is the most sensitive, because it points fingers.  I always emphasize to visitors that I’ve never seen any evidence of malfeasance, just indications of error.

     By far, the error most often reported to me is Big Boy’s bookkeeping.  The story goes that, with the death of Col. Tom in 1946, the academy lost its steady hand on the fiscal wheel.  As Brett Thompson ’75 told me a couple of years ago, Tom ran the school “like a business.”  Meanwhile, Eugene Humphrey’s ’54 told me that his parents, Ollie and Marie, who worked in the kitchen, received rent-free accommodation in one of Charles’ houses and a set of fine dinnerware.  Col. John Ronald Green (superintendent 1981-82) told me he learned about Charles having Christmas baskets left on every Ft. Defiance doorstep but that Col. Savedge blamed this largesse for contributing to the school’s financial straits.  Then, as described in Emmet Rhoades’ 1946 history, there was the practice, started by the Professor, of accepting students on barter (p. 48).  All of these could’ve hindered cash flow, trivially in the boom years but enough to force a reckoning when the culture and economy turned toxic.  The picture emerges of CSR2 as a man supremely skilled for his roles with students, sports, and public relations, but not with money.  His heart was just too big.  As his granddaughter, Linda Livick, famously said in the AMA Way documentary, “[w]hen he died, there was about $200 in his bank account.  He always liked to share everything he had.”  This is genuinely heartwarming in what it says about the man’s character – but chilling in what it implies about his stewardship.

     It's all plausible, but I can’t document a word of it, and it matters.  All I have is hearsay (Col. Savedge tells Col. Green who tells me) or eyewitness accounts that are only potentially relevant (the gifts, the barter, and the bank account).  I’m confident Mrs. Livick knew as well as anyone about her grandfather’s estate, but it might be a red herring.  Maybe there was a firewall between his personal business and the family business.  Without documents, I don’t know, and when handling the reputation of someone who’s not here to defend himself, I have a heavy burden of proof.

     Many days after BJ finished his test, I opened the folder, glanced at a single 1951 letter, and discovered a side of Col. Roller I’d never imagined.  I saw a new thread of AMA history that I’d never considered for this period.  That was in just one letter.  Late on a Saturday weeks later, in a plot twist worthy of Paul Harvey, I finally got to read the rest of the folder and learned how deep this plotline ran and who and how much drama it involved.

     The story now makes so much more sense, but it’s also much more complicated.  There’s way too much to cover in this article.  I’m working on it for next month, but there will be no verdict or even a conclusion.  What I’ve found gives us new insight and clues to follow, but it settles nothing.  This is History playing hard-to-get.  The good news is that this gold was just sitting in arm’s reach waiting to be picked up.  We’re supremely lucky that, after many decades of neglect, so many more records remain in one place and in one piece.

     It’s long past time to start digging, and time is short, but I’m not after dirt.  I’m not looking for a villain or hero.  Like most good stories (especially true ones), I doubt it’s that simple.  This family business was as complex as its circumstances and its stakeholders.  Our thousands of fragile AMA documents are a priceless mine of information to unearth, but not because they’ll tell us who to exonerate or condemn for the loss of the school.  Instead, I hope that more primary sources will make the times and personalities of the key players more vivid and complete for the historical record and make the lessons we take from their story more sophisticated and useful.

     More to come.

     Thanks for reading.